Access to the curriculum    Links with other sites    Description of the project    Networking with EuTEACH members    Your comments
 Home Retour Curriculum Retour Access the modules Retour Modules list Retour Module C4    
SitemapPrint

Module C4 :
Health education, prevention and health promotion including school health

Entry Scenario

Entry scenario   The entry scenario addresses a variety of issues and problems associated with the module topic. It may be used at the beginning of the course to stimulate the students to identify their own needs and interests. The results may be utilized by the individual to assess own learning process, or be integrated with class objectives.

You have been recently appointed by your government as the consulting physician in charge of the health of young people (congratulations!) amongst the 6 million inhabitants of an ex-Soviet Eastern European country. You are working for the Department of Health and although you are strongly encouraged to work with other departments and national agencies, you face extensive difficulty in establishing co-operation. Epidemiological studies indicate that the country has recently witnessed a large increase in the death rate from suicide among young people younger than 20 years of age. You are required to respond as quickly as possible to this situation.

General Goals for Learners
by completing the module the participant will be able to :

  1. Recognise adolescence as a useful phase of life for preventive / promotional interventions
  2. Outline some of the theoretical frameworks of health promotion and prevention for adolescents
  3. Consider the practical issues linked to health promotion and prevention for an individual adolescent and for efforts in the school and community settings
  4. Prioritise, plan, implement and evaluate interventions at national/regional/local/individual levels

Goal 1 : Recognise adolescence as a useful phase of life for preventive / promotional interventions

Knowledge

Training Objectives
Key topics to be covered
Educational Methodology Activities, Issues, and Questions Pertinent resources
A. Understand the importance of experimentation and the exploration of various different lifestyles during this period of life

Interactive lectures

Group discussion on articles 1, 2

Lecture theme: Review the ‘functions’ of experimentation during adolescence and discuss the resulting increased possibilities for risk behaviours to become established habits. Use the following questions to illustrate some of the processes at work.

  • How many adult smokers started their habit before age 20?
  • What is the average age in your country for first sexual intercourse?
  • What is the percentage of overweight adolescents who become obese adults?
  • What is the trend over the last 10 years of cannabis use among adolescents in the countries represented?

Modules A1, C1, A6

Refs 1, 2

B.Recognize the part played by the family, peers, school, other key people and the media in shaping adolescents’ lifestyles Group discussion Task for teachers: find relevant epidemiological data showing correlation between parental or peers’ lifestyle and adolescent lifestyles (health compromising as well as health enhancing behaviours).
C.Identify the impact of cultural norms and where conflict in the adolescent’s life may occur from these norms Discuss the situation of second-generation adolescent immigrants, using examples from the participants’ homelands.   

Module A5

Ref 3

Goal 2 : Outline some of the theoretical frameworks of health promotion and prevention for adolescents

Knowledge

Training Objectives
Key topics to be covered
Educational Methodology Activities, Issues, and Questions Pertinent resources

A.  Explore theories of health behaviour and the factors that influence these behaviours in different settings

  • social learning theory
  • Prochaska’s stages of change
  • Antonovski’s sense of coherence
  • Salutogenesis and the Ottawa charter

Minilecture

Readings

Group Discussion

Lecturer provides quick review of theories, and promotes class discussion of how relevant these are to health promotion and prevention. Participants may be challenged to analyse their own experiences of changing a specific behaviour during adolescence. Refs 4 - 11

B.Understand, and integrate with an understanding of adolescent development, the concepts of:

  • anticipatory guidance
  • primary/secondary/tertiary prevention
  • health education
  • health promotion
  • community health
Group Discussion

Participants give concrete examples of interventions (on the individual, family, school, community, and country-based levels) that represent each concept.

List subjects and areas for interventions that would be relevant during each of the three phases of adolescence- early, middle and late adolescence. What would be an example of designing a preventive approach in a ‘developmentally appropriate’ way?  (Suggestion: use theme of obesity, and concept of primary prevention)

Ref 12
C.Review existing literature on the implementation, assessment and evaluation of various strategies of preventive intervention

Minilecture

Readings

Group Discussion

Lecture themes: Review the concepts of efficacy, efficiency and effectiveness of preventive interventions. Distinguish between the terms ‘process’ and ‘outcome’ evaluation. Provide an overview of the literature on the evaluation of preventive and health promotion programs for:

  • mental health & suicide
  • substance use
  • sexual behaviour
  • cardio-vascular disease
  • injuries, etc.

Compare the effectiveness of interventions aimed at changing behaviours to those targeting the modification of the environment, using examples such as teaching healthy eating behaviours versus banning sweets and soft drinks sales within schools.

Find examples of effective legal actions such as the prohibition of the sale of tobacco to those under age 18.

Discuss the importance of involving parents and families in a health prevention/promotion strategy.

Module C1

Refs 9, 13 - 17

Goal 3 : Consider the practical issues linked to health promotion and prevention for an individual adolescent, and for efforts in the school and community settings

Knowledge

Training Objectives
Key topics to be covered
Educational Methodology Activities, Issues, and Questions Pertinent resources

A. Understand the effective approaches to using each patient encounter for health promotion and prevention

  • building the communication bridge
  • motivational interviewing
  • short interventions
  • solution focused approaches

Interactive lecture

Group discussion

Group Work

Plenary discussion

Video

List the topics that are amenable to prevention within an interview/consultation with an adolescent. How can the health provider assess if promotion or prevention is needed?
Discuss the usefulness of screening instruments (esp. HEADSS), and when/how to introduce them.
Additional issues:

  • Give examples of issues which may not arise spontaneously (“hidden agenda”).
  • What are effective ways of integrating advice into a patient encounter?
  • What are the reasons that certain kinds of advice or style of advice works with teenagers?

Module A3

Refs 18 - 20

B. Explore the health provider’s options to positively modify the adolescent’s environment Class discussion

Have participants share examples of small or large changes they instigated in an adolescent’s environment (home, school, work), which have had an impact on that one patient’s health and well-being (examples: calling the school nurse, having a family meeting).

Given that a negative financial situation can influence an adolescent’s health and lifestyle, what options does a health provider have to address or modify this ‘environmental’ factor?

Refs 11, 21, 22

Skills

Training Objectives
Key topics to be covered
Educational Methodology Activities, Issues, and Questions Pertinent resources

C. Provide effective, developmentally appropriate advice to an adolescent on an individual basis and in a family counselling setting

  • guidelines for each developmental stage-objectives of an advice
  • giving session
  • expectations of parents
  • family dynamics

Group work with role play or simulated patients video

Family interview

Role play

Video of successful counselling approach

Groups practice giving advice on the following subjects, first targeted to the adolescent and then to parents of the adolescent. Discuss what is particular to each of the three developmental stages (early, middle, and late adolescence).

  • injury prevention
  • sports activity
  • nutrition
  • substance use
  • sexuality

Variation of role play: inject a negative emotional element, such as the parents are alarmed about their child’s use of substances or about their child’s sexual behaviour.  What information about the parents’ parenting style or values would be helpful to obtain?

Modules A2, A3

Refs 18 - 20

Knowledge

Training Objectives
Key topics to be covered
Educational Methodology Activities, Issues, and Questions Pertinent resources

D. Describe the concept of Health Promoting Schools and how it is effective in reducing specific problems of adolescence

  • school climate
  • peer-teacher relationships
  • active student participation
  • equity in education and health

Minilecture and discussion

Review of research on Health Promoting Schools

Against a background of information about Health Promoting Schools, class discuss what aspects in school settings make students like their schools. Discuss how to achieve an adequate school atmosphere. Is this a health promotion strategy? Invite local teachers to talk about the possibilities of incorporating ‘healthy’ school concepts in a ‘normal’ school situation. Ask participants if their local schools provide a sense of coherence. Refs 16, 23 – 25

E. Consider how to capitalize on the range of possibilities to offer health promotion and prevention in the school setting

  • health education integrated in all grades/subjects
  • targeted prevention programming or strategies(for a specific health problem or risk)
Input from teachers and other key professionals involved in school health

Invite teachers to the session and discuss with them how they could address health issues within their own courses (math, readings, biology, etc.)

Review current strategies implemented in the school setting to reduce problems such as substance misuse, unplanned pregnancy, deviant behaviour, obesity and abnormal eating patterns. What appears to account for the success or failure of any of the targeted programs? Discuss the importance of strategies that are long-term and tailored to the developmental age of each school level.

Refs 26 - 31

F. Consider the methods of involving young people in their own health promotion and prevention strategies within the school structure

  • identification of the students’ priorities and acceptable strategies
  • peer leadership, peer counselling or tutoring
  • recruitment, training, and supervision issues
Focus groups with young people involved in peer led preventive activities Question for focus group with young people: what kind of school regulations relative to health should be implemented and how should they be monitored? How do the young people wish to be involved?

G. Understand how the community setting offers possibilities for health promotion and prevention

  • concept of community health
  • professionals usually involved in c.h.
  • effect of ‘social marketing’ on young people



H. Consider specific strategies to involve young people in community health

  • peer-group intervention
  • youth councils
  • participation of young people in interventions

Lecture

Readings Field & group work

Feedback by experts

Lecture introduce the basic principles of ‘social marketing’.

Which strategies to improve the health and well being of teenagers are particularly suitable for a community level effort (e.g. violence prevention)? Participants talk about the problems in their home communities and whether there have been effective responses that impact the lives of the adolescents (e.g. safe streets).

Discuss various forms of lobbying and advocacy strategies that a health provider might engage in. Give concrete examples in the subject areas affecting adolescence.

Refs 9, 24, 32 - 35

Refs 5, 12, 17, 21, 24, 36



Goal 4: Prioritise, plan, implement and evaluate interventions at national/regional/local/individual levels

Note: This module can be run in small group discussions with supervision of the teacher(s). Each group is invited to go through the various steps described below with the task of designing an intervention, which is then presented and discussed within a plenary. See appendix for example scenarios.

Skills

Training Objectives
Key topics to be covered
Educational Methodology Activities, Issues, and Questions Pertinent resources

A. Follow the steps involved in selecting an intervention

  1. In a given setting, identify the needs and problems of young people, based on available data.
  2. Select priorities which need intervention
  3. Identify the stake-holders who have an interest in preventive activities, and involve them in the selection process

Group discussions

Surveying young people

Data collection

Focus groups

Delphi survey

Questions to address:

  • Do specific subgroups of adolescents have special needs?
  • How do you assess these needs? What are the sources of data available and how could you collect data (survey, focus group etc.) that could help in the prioritising?
  • How would you set priorities for interventions?
    Describe how young people, including minorities and subgroups, may be involved in this process.

List the probable groups which would have an interest in a health promotion/prevention intervention for adolescents (e.g. the parent-teacher association)

Refs 24, 32, 37, 38

Module C1

B. Follow the steps involved in designing an intervention

  1. Set specific measurable objectives
  2. Choose the appropriate design for intervention
  3. Identify professionals to be involved in running the program
  4. Identify existing resources, technical and human
  5. Chose appropriate evaluation methods and tools
  6. Make a budget and design a timeframe
  7. Get the money

Group discussions

Meet with experts

Exchange ideas with professionals involved in specific programs

On-site visit of successful programs

Programme fair (stands exhibiting various experiences and programmes,Round-table with presentation of interventions)

Considerations for the planning process:

  • In planning an intervention, focus on obstacles and resources.
  • Discuss the pros and cons of various designs / approaches. Should it be educational? Specific or non-specific? Focus on health promotion and/or on the prevention of specific problems?
  • What kind of information will be needed to answer the question “Did the program meet its objectives?” How will you collect this data? What will be the criteria for ‘success’?
  • How do you identify potential sponsors and convince them to support the project?

Identify in the participants’ own countries/regions various financial and other resources, e.g.

  • state authorities
  • national/international NGO’s
  • private foundations
  • industries

Discuss how to respond to program opponents:

  • Decision makers may feel that adolescents are in good health and don’t need resources.
  • “Adolescents would not participate anyway.”
  • “The money should rather go to the increasing population of aged people.”

Refs 24, 32, 37, 38






Ref 39

C. Demonstrate ability to implement the intervention

  1. Identify training needs of those who run the intervention and train them
  2. Prepare the materials needed
  3. Pre-test the intervention
  4. Reframe and run the program
Group discussion

Meet with those who will participate in the intervention.
Assess their competence and needs. Discuss and develop the needed materials with these people.

Important issues to discuss:

  • how to sensitise the community to the intervention
  • how to recruit professionals involved in the process
  • how to collaborate with young people
  • how to develop the appropriate tools (questionnaires, pamphlets, educational material)
Refs 9, 11, 13, 17, 39, 40

D. Perform an evaluation

  1. Select appropriate indicators (process/outcome) and how to gather the data
  2. Assess the outcomes from the young people’s viewpoint as well as the viewpoint of  those in charge of the program
  3. Disseminate the results
Group discussion

Important issues to discuss:

  • how to monitor the implementation (with the target audience or/and the professionals involved)
  • Are the outcomes measurable and how? Do they fit with the intervention’s objectives?
  • What has to be done if the outcomes are not reached?
  • Identify target groups for the dissemination of the results.
Refs 9, 11, 13, 17, 39, 40

References

  1. Currie C, Roberts C, Morgan A, Smith R, Settertobulte W, Samdal O, Barnekow Rasmussen V. Young people's health in context. Health Behaviour in School-aged Children (HBSC) study: international report from the 2001/2002 survey. Copenhagen: World Health Organisation, 2004.

  2. Michaud PA, Blum RW, Ferron C. "Bet you I will!" Risk or experimental behavior during adolescence? Arch Pediatr Adolesc Med 1998; 152:224-6.

  3. Michaud P, Blum R, Slap G. Cross-cultural surveys of adolescent health and behaviour: progress and problems. Soc Sci Med 2001; 53:1237-1246.

  4. Centre for Reviews and Dissemination. http://www.york.ac.uk/inst/crd/welcome.htm: National Health Service, 2001.

  5. Anonymous. Ottawa chart for Health Promotion; an international conference. Ottawa: Health and Welfare Canada, 1986.

  6. Antonovsky A. The salutogenic model as theory to guide health promotion. Health Promotion International 1986; 1:1-18.

  7. Bandura A. Social foundations of thoughts and action: a social cognitive theory. Englewood Cliffs: Prentice Hall, 1986.

  8. Grossman R, Skala K. Health promotion and organisational development : developing settings for health. Vienna: World Health organisation, 1993.
  9. Millstein S, Petersen A, Nightingale E. Promoting the Health of Adolescents. New Directions for the Twenty-First Century. Oxford: Oxford University Press, 1993.

  10. Gager P, Elias M. Implementing prevention programs in high-risk environments: Application of the resiliency paradigm. American Journal of Orthopsychiatry 1997; 67:363-373.

  11. Whitelaw S, Baxendale A, Bryce Ca. "Settings" based health promotion: a review. Health Promotion International 2001; 16:339-353.

  12. St.Pierre T, Kaltreider D. Strategies  for involving parents of high risk youth in drug prevention: A three-year longitudinal study in boys and girls clubs. Journal of Community Psychology 1997; 25:473-485.

  13. Pineault R, Daveluy C. La planification de la santé: concepts, méthodes, stratégies. Montréal: Ed Agence d'Arc, 1986.

  14. Bury J. Evidence base in health promotion :Why bother? Soc & PrevMedizin 2003; 48:277-278.

  15. Speller V, Learmouth A, Harrison D. The search for evidence of effective health promotion. BMJ 1997; 315:361-363.

  16. World Health Organisation. Comprehensive School Health Education. Suggested Guidelines for Action. Geneva: WHO, 1992.

  17. World Health Organization. Programming for adolescent health and development. Geneva: World Health Organization, 1999.

  18. Goldenring J, Rosen D. Getting into adolescent heads: An essential update. Cont Pediatrics 2004; 21:64-90.

  19. American Medical Association. AMA Guidelines for adolescent preventive services : Recommendations and rationale: William and Wilkins, 1994.

  20. World Health Organization. The health of young people. Geneva: World Health Organization, 1993.

  21. Resnick MD, Bearman PS, Blum RW. Protecting adolescents from harm: Findings from the National Longitudinal study  on adolescent health. Journal of the American Medical Association 1997; 278:823-32.

  22. Resnick MD. Protective factors, resiliency, and healthy youth development. Adolescent Medicine: State of the Art Reviews 2000; 11:157-64.

  23. Hagquist C, Starrin B. Health education in school: from information to empowerment models. Health Promotion International 1997; 12:225-232.

  24. Michaud P. Prevention and health promotion in schools and community settings: A commentary on the international perspective. J Adolesc Health 2003; 33:219-225.

  25. World Health Organisation. The European Network of Health Promoting Schools. Copenhagen: World Health Organisation, 1993.

  26. Patton G, Glover S, Bond L, Butler H, Godfrey C, Di Pietro G. The gatehouse project: a systematic approach to mental health promotion in secondary schools. Australian and New Zealand Journal of Psychiatry 2000; 34:586-593.
  27. Sallis J, McKenzie T, Alacaraz J, Kolody B, Faucette N, Hovell M. The effect of a 2-year physical education program (SPARK)  on physical activity and fitness in elementary school students. Amer J Public Health 1997; 87:1328-1334.

  28. Tobler N. School-based adolescent drug prevention programs: 1998 meta-analysis. J Primary Prevention 2000; 20:275-336.

  29. Williams C, Bollella M, Strobino B, Spark A, Nicklas T, Tolosi L, Pittmann B. Healthy-start: outcome of an intervention to promote a heart healthy diet in preschool children. J Am Coll Nutr 2002; 21:62-71.

  30. World Health Organisation. Life skills education for children and adolescents in schools. Geneva, 1993.

  31. Ellickson P, Bell R, McGuigan K. Preventing adolescent drug use : long-term results of a junior high school programme. Amer J Public Health 1993; 83.

  32. Berg-Kelly K. From epidemiology to community health. J Adol Health 2003; 33:226-230.

  33. Kelder S, Perry C, Lytle L, Klepp K. Community-wide youth nutrition education: long-term outcomes of the Minnesota Heart Health Program. Health Education Research 1995; 10:119-131.

  34. Sowden A, Arblaster L. Community interventions for preventing smoking in young people. Oxford: The Cochrane Library, 2000.

  35. Ling J, Franklin B, Lindsteadt J, Gearon S. Social Marketing: Its Place in Public Health. Annual Review of Public Health 1992; 13:341-362.

  36. Comité français d'éducation pour la santé. L'approche par les pairs pour la santé des adolescents. Vanves: Fondation de France et CFES, 1996.

  37. Meyer J. Using qualitative methods in health related action research. BMJ 2000; 320:178-181.

  38. Michaud P, Baudier F, Choquet M, Mansour S. La santé des adolescents: quels liens entre recherche et prévention ? Paris: Comité français d'éducation pour la santé, 1994.

  39. Baumann M, Deschamps J. Projets de recherche et mémoires en santé publique et communautaire. Paris: Centre International de l'Enfance, 1991.

  40. Blum R. Healthy youth development as a model for youth health promotion. Journal of Adolescent Health 1998; 22:368-75.

Appendix: Scenarios for use in Goal 4:

  1. You are working as a gynaecologist in the family planning of a middle size city of 200.000 inhabitants, in a European country. You receive a call from the department of gynaecology of the hospital. They are concerned about the fact that over the last months, they have had to perform an unusually high number of abortions among immigrant adolescents from South America and ask you to do something about it.

  2. You live in a city of 500.000 inhabitants of an Eastern European country and you work as the consultant physician of a local non-profit organization that targets the issue of substance abuse among young people. The organization has opened a special day care center for young people who are heroin users. However, the age range of the patients is over 20 years of age and you know from the street workers that many younger adolescents are poly-drug users, but you don’t know how to reach them. The organization asks you to suggest possible avenues to attract younger adolescents who abuse drugs, and to set up prevention strategies.

  3. You work in a school as a part-time school physician in a suburb of a city of 3 million people located in a large European country. There are 1200 pupils aged 11 to 18 years, a lot of them living in poor socio-economic circumstances. The school nurse is concerned about the number of young people who are getting severely obese (BMI > 30). She has tried to set-up a daily hot-line to give advices to these adolescents but they don’t call….

  4. You can use entry scenario as well.
  GoTop