 |
Module A6: Exploratory/ risk behaviours and resilience
Entry Scenario
The entry scenario addresses a variety of issues and problems associated with the module topic. It may be used at the beginning of the course to stimulate the students to identify their own needs and interests. The results may be utilized by the individual to assess own learning process, or be integrated with class objectives.
A 16 year-old boy called Tom comes to your office because of repeated fainting episodes. He is dressed punk-style and wears a red and green Mohican-type haircut. After being assured of confidentiality, he says he is living “at the limit” and enjoying it. Although he denies smoking or using illegal drugs, he usually drinks quite heavily (15 to 20 beers per night) with his friends on weekends. Recently he was involved in a car crash in which his best friend (aged 21) was driving while intoxicated, and neither boy was wearing a seatbelt. As a result, Tom spent 24 hours in the hospital emergency room. Because his parents are divorced, Tom is living with his father, although he admits that he stops by home only when he needs cash or food. More often than not he sleeps at a friend’s place, or perhaps on the street, and he tends to skip meals. When asked about school, he answers that life is too short to spend it studying, and the same applies to working.
General Goals for Learners by completing the module the participant will be able to :
- Understand the concepts of exploratory behaviours, risk behaviours, resilience and protective factors in the context of bio-psychosocial developmentII.
- Enhance the attitudes and skills needed to deal effectively with young people who engage in exploratory/ risk behaviours
- Apply resilience theory to effective strategies of primary and secondary prevention for individual patients
Goal 1 : Understand the concepts of exploratory behaviours, risk behaviours, resilience and protective factors in the context of bio-psychosocial development
Knowledge
Training Objectives Key topics to be covered
|
Educational Methodology
|
Activities, Issues, and Questions
|
Pertinent resources
|
|
A. Define and clarify the terminology relating to adolescents and risk - risk
- youth at risk
- risk behaviour
- risk-taking behaviour
- exploratory and experimental behaviours
- perception of risk
|
Minilecture
Group work
|
Issues that may be included in lecture: the question of genetic versus environmental influences; the short and long term impacts on health; gender specific issues in exploratory behaviours. Group tasks: - List at least 5 exploratory behaviours, for boys and girls separately, that are prevalent in the local contexts represented.
- Estimate prevalence of these behaviours and compare with existing data from country or regional level. (Data provided by teacher)
- Discuss the following questions: when does exploratory behaviour become risk-taking behaviour? What is sensation-seeking behaviour?
Discuss the concept of clustering of risk-taking behaviours.
|
Ref 1
|
|
B. Describe how exploratory behaviour may be useful in accomplishing developmental tasks of adolescence
|
Group work
|
Behaviour examples: a 14 year-old girl is sexually active without protection against pregnancy and STD’s; a 16 year-old boy smokes 1 pack cig/day and uses cannabis on weekends. Using the grid on bio-psychosocial development in appendix 1, identify characteristics of developmental stages that might drive the behaviour; try to find developmental processes where the behaviour might be instrumental to promote developmental tasks. How might asynchronous pubertal maturation (earlier, later than peers, physical development preceding cognitive development) affect risk-behaviour?
|
Refs 2, 3 Appendix 1 Module A1
|
Attitudes
Training Objectives Key topics to be covered
|
Educational Methodology
|
Activities, Issues, and Questions
|
Pertinent resources
|
|
C. Explore the attitudes and perceptions of adolescents on exploratory and risk behaviour
|
Group work with input from adolescents
|
Discuss how the misperception of social norms and the erroneous estimations (over and under) of their peers’ behaviour affect an adolescent’s own risk behaviour. Question: Could abstinence or fear-based prevention strategies be ineffective or even counterproductive by inducing “reactance” (“forbidden fruit” phenomenon”)? Discuss the drawbacks of using the concept of risk as a focal point in one’s clinical practice with adolescents
|
Ref 1
|
Knowledge
Training Objectives Key topics to be covered
|
Educational Methodology
|
Activities, Issues, and Questions
|
Pertinent resources
|
|
D. Define the concept of resilience, using Luthar’s definition as a starting point “… a process which refers to the presence of a threat to a person and evidence of positive adaptation of the adolescent despite adversity. “
|
Readings Interactive lecture
|
Lecture presents key themes from the recent understanding of resilience, such as - resilience as a multifaceted concept
- resilience as a dynamic interaction between risk and protective processes
- resilience as a process or resilience as an outcome
- universality of stress
- effect of the meaning one ascribes to stress
|
Refs 4- 9
|
|
E. Define the concept of protective factors and identify protective factors in different domains of an adolescent’s life
|
Case study and group discussion
|
Reading, handouts or interactive lecture presents theories/definitions of protective factors. Class discusses case study, as well as other examples from participants’ personal experiences. What factors contribute to making the example individuals resilient? Case study: A 23 year-old nurse remarks that she had a difficult childhood and many reasons that could have led to personal failure, including an alcoholic and schizophrenic mother, the early death of her father, and socio-economic problems. She fondly remembers her grandmother who often had to care for her, and who encouraged her to go into nursing.
|
Refs 10,11
|
Goal 2 : Enhance the attitudes and skills needed to deal effectively with young people who engage in exploratory/ risk behaviours
Attitudes
Training Objectives Key topics to be covered
|
Educational Methodology
|
Activities, Issues, and Questions
|
Pertinent resources
|
|
A. Clarify one’s own attitude towards people that undertake exploratory/risk behaviours
|
Small group work
|
To increase awareness of personal attitudes and to identify the values underlying these attitudes, participants work in small groups with the following questions: Which adolescent behaviours bother you the most? Which behaviours do you hope your own children will avoid? Do you know of any personal reason why you may react negatively to exploratory/risk behaviours? Which of your values are violated or enforced by the behaviours? How much is your opinion affected by the societal values around you?
|
|
Skills
Training Objectives Key topics to be covered
|
Educational Methodology
|
Activities, Issues, and Questions
|
Pertinent resources
|
|
B. Increase skill in using the HEADSSS (Home, Education, Eating, Activities, Drugs, Sexuality, Suicide, Safety) approach to recognize and assess exploratory/risk behaviour and factors
|
Reading or minilecture Group work
|
Participants review the philosophy of the HEADSSS approach (possibly before class). In small groups, participants practice using a HEADSSS interview with a simulated patient or in role play. Example of patient: a 15 year-old girl with multiple body piercings comes to a clinic with flu symptoms. (Video taping of the role play would facilitate feedback sessions.)
|
Ref 12 Websites 1, 2 Module A3
|
|
C. Demonstrate a non-judgemental, autonomy-supporting approach toward the adolescent
|
(Above group continues)
|
Group discusses how a non-judgmental, autonomy-supporting attitude would be conveyed to an adolescent patient. Specifically provide feedback to the role playing participants (from B. above) about this skill.
|
|
Goal 3 : Apply resilience theory to effective strategies of primary and secondary prevention for individual patients.
Skills
|
Training Objectives Key topics to be covered
|
Educational Methodology
|
Activities, Issues, and Questions
|
Pertinent resources
|
|
A. Utilize effective strategies for primary and secondary prevention of risk-behaviours in adolescents
|
Class discussion
Role play Performance group
|
Discuss the following elements of preventive strategies that work with young people: - Emphasize short-term consequences.
- Personalize the health problem.
- Reach the adolescent in his/her “stage of change”.
- Support adolescent’s own resources.
- Use an autonomy- supporting style.
- Align preventive messages with those from families, schools and communities
Role play, incorporating the above principles into a counselling session. Sample patients: a 16 year-old boy who smokes has tried once to quit smoking. A 15 year-old girl who sporadically drinks too much is convinced that using condoms is enough to prevent pregnancy.
|
Ref 13
|
|
B. Incorporate resilience theory into counselling an individual adolescent
|
Class work Role play
|
Using appendix 2 as a basis of the counselling approach, class work on the following case study: Case: 16 year-old Richard is brought to consultation by his mother (a divorced professional) because she is concerned about his cannabis and alcohol use. She caught him smoking cannabis this morning before going to school. Richard was a good student until recently; he plays in a band with friends from school as well as a teacher. He claims not to care much about academic success because he is sure he will start a successful career as a music company owner. His mother voices great disappointment about this choice, saying that she wants her son to become a college teacher.
|
Refs 9, 10, 11, 14
|
References
- Michaud P.A., Blum RW, Ferron C. « Bet you I will ! » Risk or experimental behaviour during adolescence? Arch Pediatrics Adolesc Med, 1998. 152:224-226
- Jessor R.Risk behaviour in adolescence: a psychosocial framework for understanding and action. J. Adolesc Health 1991; 12:597-605.
- Compas BE, Hinden BR, and Gerhardt Ca. Adolescent Development: Pathways and processes of risk and resilience. Annu Rev Psycho. 1995; 46:265-93.
- Blum RW. Healthy youth development as a model for youth health promotion. J Adolesc Health, 1998. 22: p. 368-75.
- Lindström B. The meaning of resilience. Int J Adolesc Med Health, 2001. 13(1): p. 7-12.
- Rutter, M. Resilience: some conceptual considerations. J Adolesc Health, 1993. 14(626-31).
- Luthar SS, Cichetti D, Becker B. The construct of resilience: A critical Evaluation and Guidelines for Future Work. Child Devlpmt 2000 71:543-562
- Olsson CA, Bond L, Burns JM et al. Adolescent resilience: a concept analysis. J Adolesc 2003;26:1-11.
- Michaud PA. La resilience: un regard neuf sur les soins et la prévention. Arch Pédiatr 1999; 6:827-31.
- Resnick, MD, Bearman PS, Blum RW, et al. Protecting adolescents from harm: Findings from the National Longitudinal study on adolescent health. JAMA, 1997. 278: p. 823-32.
- Resnick, MD. Protective factors, resiliency, and healthy youth development. Adolescent Medicine: State of the Art Reviews, 2000. 11(1): p. 157-64.
- Goldenring JM and Rosen DS. Getting into adolescent heads: an essential update. Contemporary Pediatrics 2004; 21 (1): 64-90.
- Prochaska J, DiClemente CC. Toward a comprehensive model of change. In: Treating addictive behaviors: processes of change. New York: Plenum; 1987.
- Loewenson, PR. and Blum RW. The resilient adolescent: implications for the pediatrician. Pediatric Annals, 2001. 30(2): p. 76-80.
Further reading:
Haggerty R, Sherrod L, Garmezy N, and Rutter M (Eds.). Stress, Risk and Resilience in Children and Adolescents: Processes, Mechanisms and Interventions. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press 1996.
Websites:
- http://www.complab.nymc.edu/pediatrics/HEADSS.htm
- http://www.health.state.mn.us/divs/chs/adolescent/long.html
APPENDIX 1
|
Development
|
Early Adolescence (10-13/14y)
|
Mid Adolescence (14/15-17)
|
Late Adolescence (ca. 17-21)
|
Biological
|
|
|
|
Psychological
|
|
|
|
Social
|
|
|
|
Use the following list as a basis for the case discussion.
Essential components:
- Significant adults
- Significant places
- Significant activities
- Significant relationships
- Future projects
- Spirituality/ sense of a meaning of life
- Others
|
 |